
You switch on your out-of-office message, head away, and nobody receives it. When outlook automatic replies not working happens, senders hear nothing, and you only discover the silence when you return to a pile of unanswered mail. The fault is rarely a broken Outlook. It is usually the date range, the account type, a rule that grabs the mail first, or a setting that blocks replies to people outside your organisation.
This guide works through the causes in order, from re-checking the switch to rebuilding your Outlook profile. Automatic replies are a server feature, so many fixes are checked in Outlook on the web as well as in the desktop app. Work through the fixes one at a time, and send yourself a test message after each one. A test reply that arrives is the only proof that counts.
Table of Contents
- Why This Error Happens
- Quick Checks
- Diagnosing the Problem
- Fix 1: Turn Automatic Replies Off and Back On
- Fix 2: Check the Start Date, End Date and Time Zone
- Fix 3: Check Both Message Boxes: Inside and Outside Your Organisation
- Fix 4: Allow Replies to People Outside Your Organisation
- Fix 5: Check the Contacts-Only Limit on External Replies
- Fix 6: Send a Test Email From an Account That Has Not Emailed You Yet
- Fix 7: Check That Your Account Type Supports Automatic Replies
- Fix 8: Set the Replies Up in Outlook on the Web
- Fix 9: Check Inbox Rules That Move, Delete or Answer Mail First
- Fix 10: Make Sure the Right Mailbox Is Selected
- Fix 11: Check That Outlook Is Connected and Mail Is Flowing
- Fix 12: Remove an Old Out-of-Office Rule That Conflicts
- Fix 13: Ask Your Admin to Check the External Replies Policy
- Fix 14: Free Up Space When the Mailbox Is Full
- Fix 15: Create a Fresh Outlook Profile and Repair Office
- What to Avoid
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
- Helpful Official Resources
Why This Error Happens
Automatic replies are sent by the mail server, not by the Outlook app on your PC. When a message arrives, the server checks whether automatic replies are on, whether the date range covers today, whether the sender is inside or outside your organisation, and whether that sender has already received a reply. If any check fails, no reply is sent, and Outlook shows no error. These are the reasons that happens most often.
1. The Time Range Has Ended or Has Not Started
Automatic replies set to a date range only run inside that range. A reply set to end on Friday stops on Friday, even if you are still away on Monday. A reply with the start and end dates the wrong way round never runs at all. Time zone mistakes have the same effect: a range set in the wrong zone starts and ends hours early or late. The switch can look “on” while the range quietly keeps it silent.
2. The Account Type Does Not Support Automatic Replies
Automatic replies are an Exchange and Microsoft 365 feature. Gmail, Yahoo, and other POP and IMAP accounts do not support the server-side switch at all, so the Automatic Replies button is missing or does nothing for those accounts. People with a personal account added alongside a work account often set the reply on the wrong one, or expect a feature their account type cannot provide.
3. External Replies Are Switched Off
Outlook keeps two separate messages: one for people inside your organisation, and one for people outside it. If the outside message is empty, or if replies outside the organisation are switched off, colleagues get a reply while clients and friends hear nothing. This split is deliberate — it stops out-of-office details leaking to strangers — but it looks exactly like a fault when only half your senders get an answer.
4. Outlook Only Replies Once to Each Sender
The server sends one automatic reply to each sender, then stays silent for later messages from the same person during the same out-of-office period. This stops reply loops and inbox flooding. It also means the most common test — emailing yourself twice from the same account — falsely suggests outlook automatic replies not working, when the first message did receive a reply and the second correctly did not.
5. A Rule Intercepts the Message First
Inbox rules run before automatic replies in some setups, and a rule that moves, deletes, or forwards a message can take it out of the path that triggers a reply. A rule that replies with a template can conflict with the server reply, and a rule that marks mail as read or moves it to a folder can hide the fact that a reply was never triggered. Rules are invisible to senders, so the silence looks like a server fault.
6. An Admin Policy Blocks External Replies
In work and school accounts, the organisation’s administrator controls whether automatic replies may leave the organisation at all. A policy that blocks external replies overrides anything you set in Outlook, with no warning on your screen. The inside message keeps working, the outside message never leaves, and only the admin can change the policy. This cause is common in larger organisations and impossible to fix from your own settings.
Quick Checks
Two minutes before the deep fixes.
- Open Automatic Replies and confirm the switch is actually on, not just the message typed.
- Check the start and end dates cover today, and the time zone matches where you are.
- Check whether colleagues get a reply while outside senders do not, or nobody gets one.
- Check whether the account is a work or school account, or a personal POP or IMAP account.
- Check whether you tested with a sender who already emailed you during this absence.
- Think about what changed — did outlook automatic replies not working begin after an account change, a new PC, or a move to the new Outlook?
Diagnosing the Problem
| Symptom | Cause | Go to Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Nobody receives a reply at all | Switch off, or date range wrong | Fix 1 |
| Replies stopped on a certain day | End date passed, or time zone wrong | Fix 2 |
| Colleagues get replies, outsiders do not | External replies switched off | Fix 4 |
| First test worked, later tests silent | One reply per sender rule | Fix 6 |
| Automatic Replies button is missing | Account type does not support it | Fix 7 |
| Replies work on the web, not on desktop | Desktop setting not synced to server | Fix 8 |
| Some senders get replies, others do not | Inbox rule intercepting mail | Fix 9 |
| Replies work inside only, admin-run account | Organisation policy blocking external replies | Fix 13 |
Fix 1: Turn Automatic Replies Off and Back On
A setting that looks on is not always active. The switch can fall out of sync with the server after an update, an account repair, or a move between the classic and new Outlook. Turning the feature fully off, saving, and turning it on again forces Outlook to write a fresh setting to the server. It is the simplest fix, and it works surprisingly often.

- In classic Outlook, open File, then Info, and click Automatic Replies.
- In the new Outlook, open Settings, then Accounts, then Automatic Replies.
- Select Do not send automatic replies, or switch the toggle off, and click OK or Save.
- Close the Automatic Replies window completely.
- Reopen Automatic Replies and select Send automatic replies, or switch the toggle on.
- Re-enter your message, check the dates, and click OK or Save.
- Send a test message from a second account and check that a reply arrives.
- Do not just retype the message and click OK — the off-then-on cycle is the part that resyncs the server.
- If the Automatic Replies button is missing entirely, skip to Fix 7, because the account type is the cause.
- After turning replies on, look for the yellow banner in Outlook that says automatic replies are on — its absence means the setting did not save.
- When outlook automatic replies not working follows an Outlook update, this resync is the fix that most often ends it.
Fix 2: Check the Start Date, End Date and Time Zone
A date range that does not cover today keeps replies silent, however correct everything else is. The two classic mistakes are an end date in the past and a start date still in the future, both easy to make when setting up replies in a hurry. Time zone errors shift the whole range by hours, so a reply set for “Monday” in the wrong zone may not start until Tuesday morning.
- Open Automatic Replies as in Fix 1.
- Check the Only send during this time range box, and read the start date and time carefully.
- Read the end date and time, and confirm today falls between the two.
- Check the time zone shown, and change it if it does not match your location.
- If the dates are wrong, correct them, or untick the time-range box so replies run until you switch them off.
- Click OK or Save, then reopen the window to confirm the dates saved as you set them.
- Send a test message from a second account and check that a reply arrives.
- An end time of midnight means the range ends as the day begins, not as it ends — set the end to the last evening of your absence.
- If you travel across time zones while away, the server uses the zone set in the reply, not the zone your phone is in.
- Unticking the time-range box is the safest choice when dates keep confusing the setup, because the replies then run until you turn them off by hand.
- Recheck the dates after any edit: Outlook sometimes resets the range when the message text is changed.
Fix 3: Check Both Message Boxes: Inside and Outside Your Organisation
Work and school accounts have two message boxes: one for senders inside your organisation, and one for senders outside it. The outside box is a separate tab or section, and it is easy to write the inside message and forget the outside one. An empty outside message means outside senders get nothing, even though the feature is on and colleagues get replies.
- Open Automatic Replies as in Fix 1.
- Click the Inside My Organization tab and check your message is there.
- Click the Outside My Organization tab and check whether it has a message.
- If the outside box is empty, type the message you want outside senders to receive.
- Keep the outside message short, and leave out private details such as your personal phone number.
- Click OK or Save, then reopen the window to confirm both messages saved.
- Test with one message from a colleague and one from a personal account outside the organisation.
- In the new Outlook and Outlook on the web, the outside option appears as a checkbox and a second message area rather than a tab — check both areas either way.
- The inside and outside messages can differ: colleagues can get your mobile number, while outside senders get a general contact address.
- If the outside tab is missing, your account may not support external replies, and Fix 7 and Fix 13 apply.
- A reply that works for colleagues but not for anyone else is almost always this fix, not a server fault.
Fix 4: Allow Replies to People Outside Your Organisation
Even with an outside message written, replies to outside senders stay off until the outside option itself is switched on. In classic Outlook the outside tab has its own “send replies” choice, and in the new Outlook a checkbox controls it. This switch defaults to off in some setups, so check it directly rather than assuming the message alone is enough.
- Open Automatic Replies as in Fix 1.
- Open the Outside My Organization tab, or find the outside-organisation section.
- Confirm the option to send replies outside the organisation is selected or ticked.
- If it is off, switch it on and check the outside message text is present.
- Click OK or Save, then reopen the window to confirm the choice saved.
- Send a test message from a personal email account outside the organisation.
- Check the personal inbox for the automatic reply, allowing a few minutes for delivery.
- Allow a few minutes for the first test reply — server replies are not instant, and impatience causes many false “still broken” verdicts.
- If the outside option is greyed out, an admin policy controls it, and Fix 13 is the path forward.
- Do not put sensitive details in the outside message: it goes to anyone who emails you, including strangers and mailing lists.
- When outlook automatic replies not working affects only outside senders, this switch and Fix 3 together solve most cases.
Fix 5: Check the Contacts-Only Limit on External Replies
The new Outlook and Outlook on the web offer a “send replies only to contacts” choice for external senders. When it is on, only senders in your contacts list receive a reply, and everyone else hears nothing. It is a sensible privacy choice, but it looks like a fault when a new client or a stranger emails you and gets silence. Check the choice and decide deliberately.
- Open Automatic Replies in the new Outlook or Outlook on the web.
- Find the external replies section and the contacts-only option.
- Check whether Send replies only to contacts is ticked.
- If it is ticked and you want all outside senders to get a reply, untick it.
- If you want the limit, keep it ticked, and add important outside contacts to your contacts list.
- Click Save, then reopen the settings to confirm the choice saved.
- Test with a message from an outside account that is not in your contacts.
- The contacts-only limit uses the contacts in your mailbox, not the contacts on your phone, so check the mailbox contacts list.
- Classic Outlook does not show this option in the same way — if you set replies in classic Outlook, check the setting again on the web.
- Keeping the limit on is the safer choice for most people, as long as it is a deliberate choice and not an accident.
- A reply that reaches some outside senders but not others is the signature of this setting, not of a broken server.
Fix 6: Send a Test Email From an Account That Has Not Emailed You Yet
The server replies once per sender per out-of-office period. That single rule invalidates most home testing, because people test from the same account again and again, and the second and third messages correctly get no reply. A valid test needs a fresh sender — an account that has not emailed you since the replies were switched on.

- Pick a second email account that has not emailed your Outlook address during this absence.
- From that account, send a short new message to your Outlook address.
- Wait five minutes, then check the second account’s inbox for the automatic reply.
- Check the spam and junk folders of the second account as well.
- If the reply arrived, automatic replies are working, and earlier silent tests were repeat senders.
- If no reply arrived, keep the test message as evidence and move to Fix 7.
- For each later fix, test again with a different fresh sender account, or turn replies off and on to reset the once-per-sender record.
- Turning replies off and back on resets the record of who has already received a reply, which makes retesting from the same account valid again.
- Mailing lists and bulk senders usually do not receive automatic replies, by design, so do not use a newsletter as a test.
- The reply goes to the sender’s inbox, not to your own — check the sending account, not the Outlook account.
- When outlook automatic replies not working is reported after repeated self-tests, this fix alone often closes the case.
Fix 7: Check That Your Account Type Supports Automatic Replies
Automatic replies need an Exchange or Microsoft 365 mailbox. POP and IMAP accounts — including most Gmail, Yahoo, and internet-provider accounts added to Outlook — have no server-side automatic replies, so the button is missing and no setting in Outlook can create the feature. Knowing your account type saves hours of searching for a switch that cannot exist.
- In Outlook, open File, then Info, and read the account type under your email address.
- If it says Microsoft Exchange or Microsoft 365, the account supports automatic replies — move to Fix 8.
- If it says IMAP or POP, the account does not support server automatic replies.
- For an IMAP or POP account, check whether the mail provider offers its own vacation reply in webmail, and set it there.
- Alternatively, create an inbox rule that replies with a template — but note it only runs while Outlook is open on your PC.
- If you have both a work and a personal account in Outlook, confirm you set replies on the work account, not the personal one.
- After setting the provider’s own vacation reply, test it with a fresh sender as in Fix 6.
- The missing Automatic Replies button is the clearest sign of an unsupported account type — it is not a fault to fix in Outlook.
- A rule-based reply for a POP or IMAP account stops the moment you close Outlook or switch the PC off, so the provider’s webmail setting is the reliable path.
- Gmail’s own vacation responder lives in Gmail settings on the web, not in Outlook, and it works whether Outlook is open or not.
- If your work account was recently migrated to a new system, confirm with IT that the mailbox is still an Exchange mailbox.
Fix 8: Set the Replies Up in Outlook on the Web
Outlook on the web writes the automatic-replies setting directly to the server, with no desktop sync in between. When the desktop setting and the server disagree, the web setting wins and reveals the truth. Setting replies up on the web also rules out every desktop cause at once: a bad profile, a stuck sync, or a confused app.
- Open Outlook on the web in a browser and sign in with the same account.
- Open Settings, then Accounts, then Automatic replies.
- Switch Turn on automatic replies on.
- Set the time range, or leave it off so replies run until you switch them off.
- Type the message, tick the outside-organisation box if you want outside replies, and click Save.
- Send a test message from a fresh sender account and check for the reply.
- If the web setting works, leave it in place — the desktop app will show the same setting once it syncs.
- The web setting and the desktop setting are the same server setting, so changing one changes the other after syncing.
- If the web setting also fails, the cause is the account, the policy, or the dates — not the desktop app — and Fixes 7, 12, and 13 apply.
- Sign in on the web with the exact account that should send the replies, not a personal account with a similar name.
- A reply set on the web keeps working when your PC is off, because the server sends it — that is the point of the server feature.
Fix 9: Check Inbox Rules That Move, Delete or Answer Mail First
Inbox rules act on incoming mail, and a rule that moves a message to a folder, deletes it, or forwards it can take the message out of the path that triggers an automatic reply. A rule that replies with a template can also conflict with the server reply. Reviewing the rules, and testing with them paused, separates a rule fault from a server fault.
- In Outlook, open File, then Manage Rules & Alerts, or Settings, then Mail, then Rules on the web.
- Read every rule, and note any that move, delete, forward, or reply to incoming mail.
- Untick or pause the rules that touch incoming mail, one at a time, starting with the newest.
- Send a test message from a fresh sender after pausing each rule.
- If replies start working, the last rule you paused is the cause — edit or delete it.
- Re-enable the other rules one at a time, testing after each, so you keep only the rules you need.
- Save the final rule list and test once more with a fresh sender.
- Rules run in order from the top, and a rule with “stop processing more rules” can block every rule below it, including the reply path.
- A rule created for a previous absence, or by an old add-in, is the most common culprit — check for rules you do not remember creating.
- If rules misbehave more widely, our guide to Outlook rules not working covers rule repairs in depth.
- Client-only rules, marked as such in the list, run only when Outlook is open, while server rules run always — the distinction matters for testing.
Fix 10: Make Sure the Right Mailbox Is Selected
People with more than one mailbox — a personal mailbox, a shared mailbox, a delegate’s mailbox — often set automatic replies on the wrong one. The setting saves correctly, the banner appears, and the wrong mailbox sends the replies while the mailbox everyone emails stays silent. Checking which mailbox is selected takes seconds and ends the confusion.

- In Outlook, look at the folder pane and confirm which mailbox is the one people email.
- Open File, then Info, and check the account shown at the top is that mailbox.
- If you manage a shared mailbox, open its settings specifically, not your own mailbox settings.
- In Outlook on the web, use the account switcher at the top right to open the shared mailbox directly.
- Set the automatic replies on the correct mailbox, with the correct message and dates.
- Remove or switch off any reply set on the wrong mailbox, so it does not confuse senders.
- Test by emailing the mailbox address itself, from a fresh sender account.
- A shared mailbox needs its replies set on the shared mailbox, not on your personal mailbox — the two settings are independent.
- Delegates who send on behalf of someone else should check with the mailbox owner before changing that mailbox’s replies.
- If the folder pane shows two accounts with similar names, rename one in account settings to prevent future mix-ups.
- When outlook automatic replies not working affects a team inbox, the wrong-mailbox cause is more likely than a server fault.
Fix 11: Check That Outlook Is Connected and Mail Is Flowing
Automatic replies need incoming mail to trigger them. If Outlook is offline, disconnected, or stuck, no new mail arrives, and no replies go out — and the silence looks like a replies fault when it is really a connection fault. Checking the connection status and confirming new mail arrives separates the two in a minute.
- Look at the status bar at the bottom of Outlook for Connected or Working Offline.
- If it says Working Offline, open the Send / Receive tab and click Work Offline to go back online.
- Click Send/Receive All Folders and watch for new mail arriving.
- Send yourself a test message from another account and confirm it lands in the inbox.
- If no mail arrives at all, the connection or the mailbox is the fault, not the replies setting.
- Check the account password has not expired, and sign in again if Outlook asks.
- Once mail flows again, test the automatic reply with a fresh sender.
- A mailbox that receives nothing cannot reply to anything, so always confirm mail flow before blaming the replies setting.
- If mail arrives on the web but not on the desktop, the desktop account needs attention, while the server replies may already be working.
- When new mail stops arriving entirely, our guide to Outlook not receiving emails covers the connection and mailbox checks.
- Mailbox problems often travel together: if attachments also fail, our guide to Outlook not downloading attachments covers that side of the fault.
Fix 12: Remove an Old Out-of-Office Rule That Conflicts
Before server automatic replies, the usual workaround was a rule that replied with a template message. An old rule of that kind, still active, can conflict with the server reply: it may reply with an outdated message, reply twice, or block the server reply entirely. Removing the old rule lets the server feature work cleanly on its own.
- Open Manage Rules & Alerts in classic Outlook, or Rules in Outlook on the web.
- Look for a rule whose action is “reply using a specific template” or “have server reply using a message”.
- Note the rule’s name and message, in case you want to keep the wording.
- Delete the old out-of-office rule, or untick it to disable it.
- Open Automatic Replies and confirm the server setting is on, with the current message and dates.
- Send a test message from a fresh sender and check that exactly one reply arrives.
- If two replies arrive, another rule is still replying — repeat the check until only one rule-free path remains.
- A template reply rule and a server automatic reply should never run together — pick the server feature and remove the rule.
- Rules set on the web and rules set on the desktop are the same server rules, so check in one place and the change applies everywhere.
- If the old rule was set by someone else, such as a previous assistant, check with them before deleting it.
- One reply per test message is the correct result; two replies mean two mechanisms are running, and one must go.
Fix 13: Ask Your Admin to Check the External Replies Policy
In Microsoft 365 organisations, the admin controls external automatic replies through the remote domain settings in the Exchange admin centre. If the policy blocks external replies, or allows them only to contacts, your own settings cannot override it. This fix is a conversation, not a setting: you need the admin to check the policy and tell you what is allowed.
- Confirm the pattern first: inside replies work, outside replies never arrive, whatever you set.
- Note the exact behaviour, including the dates you tested and the sender addresses used.
- Contact your IT admin or help desk, and describe the pattern plainly.
- Ask them to check the remote domain setting for automatic replies to external senders.
- Ask whether the policy allows external replies, allows them only to contacts, or blocks them entirely.
- If the policy allows external replies, ask them to confirm your mailbox is covered by that policy.
- Once the admin confirms a change, test again with a fresh outside sender.
- Do not try to bypass an admin policy with a rule or a third-party tool — the policy exists to protect the organisation, and bypassing it can breach its rules.
- If the admin confirms external replies are blocked by policy, the answer is to tell outside contacts through another channel, not to keep changing your settings.
- Some organisations allow external replies only during set hours or for set groups — ask exactly what your account is allowed.
- A clear test record helps the admin help you: dates, sender addresses, and the inside-versus-outside pattern.
Fix 14: Free Up Space When the Mailbox Is Full
A full mailbox cannot receive mail properly, and a mailbox at its limit can fail to trigger automatic replies even when mail seems to arrive. Outlook warns about mailbox size, but the warnings are easy to dismiss. Emptying the deleted items, archiving old mail, and clearing large attachments restores room and restores the reply trigger.

- In Outlook, open File, then Info, then Tools, and choose Mailbox Cleanup.
- Read the mailbox size and the server quota, and see how close to the limit you are.
- Empty the Deleted Items folder, and empty the Junk Email folder.
- Use Find items larger than in the cleanup tool to find the largest messages.
- Delete or archive the largest messages you no longer need, starting with old attachments.
- Empty Deleted Items again after deleting, so the space is actually freed.
- Send a test message from a fresh sender and check that a reply arrives.
- Deleting mail only frees space after the Deleted Items folder is emptied — until then, the space is still used.
- Archiving moves old mail out of the mailbox while keeping it searchable, which suits mail you must keep.
- If mail is stuck leaving the mailbox too, our guide to Outlook emails stuck in outbox covers the sending side.
- Ask your admin about a larger quota if the mailbox fills again quickly — a quota increase beats repeated cleanups.
Fix 15: Create a Fresh Outlook Profile and Repair Office
A damaged Outlook profile can hold a stale automatic-replies setting that no on-screen change corrects, because the app keeps writing to a broken local store. A fresh profile starts clean, and an Office repair fixes damaged program files underneath. Use this fix last, after the server, account, and rule causes have all been ruled out.
- Close Outlook completely, and check no Outlook window remains open.
- Open Windows Control Panel, search for Mail, and open Mail (Microsoft Outlook).
- Click Show Profiles, then Add, and give the new profile a name.
- Add your email account to the new profile and let the mailbox sync fully.
- Set the new profile as the default in the profile list, or choose Prompt for a profile to test it first.
- Open Outlook with the new profile, set automatic replies, and test with a fresh sender.
- If the fault remains, repair Office through Settings, then Apps, then Modify, choosing Online Repair.
- Do not delete the old profile until the new one works — keep it as a fallback while you test.
- A fresh profile re-downloads the mailbox, which can take a while on a large mailbox or a slow connection.
- The repair needs an internet connection and can take twenty minutes or more — do not interrupt it.
- If the new profile fixes the fault, the old profile was the cause, and you can delete it once you are confident.
What to Avoid
- Do not test with the same sender account again and again — the server replies once per sender, so repeat tests falsely look broken.
- Do not put private details in the outside message — it goes to anyone who emails you, including strangers.
- Do not run a template reply rule and server automatic replies together — pick one mechanism and remove the other.
- Do not use pirated software, activators, or cracks to “fix” Outlook — they can damage Office and invite malware.
- Do not try to bypass an admin policy blocking external replies — ask the admin, and respect the organisation’s rules.
- Do not delete your Outlook profile before testing a new one — keep the old profile until the new one works.
- Do not leave automatic replies on after you return — switch them off, or senders will keep getting an out-of-date message.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is outlook automatic replies not working for outside senders only?
Because inside and outside replies are separate settings. The outside message may be empty, the outside switch may be off, the contacts-only limit may be on, or an admin policy may block external replies. Work through Fix 3, Fix 4, Fix 5, and Fix 13 in order: check the outside message, switch outside replies on, check the contacts limit, and ask the admin about the policy. Inside replies working proves the server feature itself is healthy.
Do automatic replies work when my computer is switched off?
Yes, for Exchange and Microsoft 365 accounts. The server sends the reply, not your PC, so replies keep going while your computer is off, asleep, or disconnected. The exception is a rule-based reply for a POP or IMAP account, which only runs while Outlook is open on your PC. If you need replies while away, use the server feature or the provider’s webmail setting, not a rule.
Why did I get only one automatic reply from someone who is away?
Because the server sends one reply per sender per out-of-office period, by design. Later messages from the same sender during the same absence get no further reply. Turning the replies off and on resets the record, so the next message from that sender gets a fresh reply. This rule stops reply loops between two people who are both away.
Can I set different messages for colleagues and for everyone else?
Yes. Classic Outlook has separate Inside and Outside tabs, and the new Outlook and Outlook on the web have a second message area for outside senders. Colleagues can receive internal details, while outside senders receive a shorter public message. Fill in both boxes deliberately, and test each one with a sender from the matching group.
Why is the Automatic Replies button missing in Outlook?
Because the account does not support the feature. POP and IMAP accounts, including Gmail and Yahoo accounts added to Outlook, have no server-side automatic replies, so Outlook hides the button. Use the mail provider’s own vacation reply in webmail instead, which works whether Outlook is open or not. If a work account is missing the button, ask your admin whether the mailbox is an Exchange mailbox.
Will automatic replies answer mailing lists and bulk mail?
Usually not. The server suppresses replies to most bulk mail, mailing lists, and automated messages, to stop reply storms. A newsletter or a notification email that gets no reply is behaving correctly, not broken. Test with a real personal message from a fresh sender account, as Fix 6 describes, for a fair result.
Conclusion
When outlook automatic replies not working leaves senders in silence, start with the switch, the dates, and the two message boxes, then check the account type and the rules, and only then involve the admin or rebuild the profile. Most cases end at the date range or the outside-organisation switch, because the feature is working and a setting is quietly holding it back. Finish by testing with a fresh sender from inside and from outside the organisation, because two replies arriving is the proof the setting is truly fixed. Switch the replies off when you return, so the next sender gets you, not your holiday message.
